Home
 »  Community
 »  Blogs
Doris' Blog

David Mendosa's Article on Normal A1C Levels


Doris' Blog
By: dorisjdickson


<< March 2009 >>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31

 Blog Entries
Islet Cells Generation - Cure? I Think Not! - Oct 01
This article in Diabetes Health discusses yet another new potential "cure."  However, yet again, it requires immunosuppressants which are not an option to me.  ...
more
Cholesterol Conundrum - Sep 21
I recently wrote about Red Yeast Rice as an alternative to statins and the fact that it actually IS a statin since they contain the same active ingredients.  You just ...
more
Red Yeast Rice - It is a Statin - Do I Take It? - Sep 10
I receive Dr. Mercola's newsletter regularly.  I don't, however, regularly read it.  My concern is the amount of "stuff" sold on the website.  However, this ...
more
Diabetic ketoacidosis at onset of type 1 diabetes remains frequent in children - Sep 08
This article in yesterday's edition of Endocrine Today makes me scratch my head.  First and foremost, had this study been conducted in 1976 in the US and not in Germany, ...
more
Inaccurate Monitors and Strips - Sep 02
Some of you may have read about the FDA's recent warning about the inaccuracy of certain test strips while taking certain medications.  Honestly, I didn't pay much attention ...
more
Posted: Mar 1, 2009 11:18
  • 1 Comment.
  • David Mendosa's Article on Normal A1C Levels

    David Mendosa (a favorite writing peer and type 2 diabetic) recently researched and wrote an article on “normal” A1C levels.  I don't entirely agree with his summation, nor do some others who responded to his article. 

    One diabetes doc, Dr Helen Hilts, spoke of the increased risk of heart disease with A1Cs that creep up to the 6.0 point (lower than the ADA recommendations).  Her A1C is 4.6.  Dr. Hilts writes:  High insulin levels  cause heart disease in 9 ways:  increasing inflammation, free radicals, and oxidant levels in the body; by raising blood pressure, triglycerides, total and LDL cholesterol, and lowering our good cholesterol (HDL); and by increasing our clotting in the bloodstream.”

    In fact, since he was refuting Dr. Bernstein’s assertions but did not contact him for clarification, the doc spoke up as well.  Here is Dr. B’s response to David:

     Hi David

    If you had contacted me with a draft of your A1c article I would have shown you the flaw.

    See DIABETES CARE :  Vol 25 pp 275-278 feb 2002 for an accurate formula converting A1C to avg BG.

     

    It's also in my book and gives an avg BG of 136 for an A1c of 6%. An A1c of 4.7 would give an average BG of 90mg/dl.  It seems to me that BGs of the US population are running too high and are PATHOLOGIC  Not NORMAL. Average does not mean normal. Just look at body weight, metabolic syndrome etc.

     

     

    I'd be glad to discuss with you the problems associated with the new conversion formulas from A1c to average BG performed by David Nathan’s ADA group.

     

     

    Dick

     

     

    PS – Note that A1cs in my book are based on avg BGs of young adults in the 1980s when people were healthier. I pointed out that we are all entitled to those BGs and they are attainable if you don’t have gastrparesis and untreated CHO craving.”

     

     

    RICHARD K BERNSTEIN, MD, FACE, FACN, FCCWS

     

    Here’s my response to the article:

    Hi David,

    I am also very fond of Dr. Bernstein and the information he has provided diabetics that just plain was not readily available without him.  I am also enormously grateful to him for his work on glucose monitors since they ADA wasn't interested. 

    I am a juvenile onset diabetic of more than 32 years.  Prior to reading Dr. Bernstein's book and other material, I maintained the recommended target of <7 and 110-140.  I have no major complications but plenty of "features" I can do without.  Several have abated or reversed themselves since I started targeting an average blood sugar of 85 and having consistent A1Cs of 5.1

    Though I haven't yet broken the 5.0 barrier I still strive to do so.  I eat far fewer carbs than recommended though not as few as Dr. Bernstein.  However, when I have cut back that far, my deviances have been far fewer - including lows.  I attribute that to less insulin, less russian roulette.

    I do have a board buddy with several more years of experience than I.  He eats more protein and fewer carbs than even I do.  He also hung for years in the 5.2/5.3 range until a few years ago when he started taking a statin.  He has since been in Dr. Bernstein's range. 

    I attribute my deviations to several things 1) Female hormones; avoid them if possible 2) Cortisol - I don't sleep well and have varying amounts of dawn phenomenon 3) Stress - THAT I have a master's degree in and it is usually accompanied by adrenalin bursts which result in short periods of insulin resistance 4) medications that also cause periods of insulin resistance (minimally, thyroid and birth control medications) 5) Incorrectly "guessing" digestion of food which tends to result in moderate lows (40-60) and the eventual digestion of the food and extra insulin to "fix"/"cover."

    When I look at all the challenges I put my body through, I suppose I'm very fortunate for attaining 5.1s so consistently.  However, I will continue to work to get < the magic 5.0.  I know how much better I feel at 5.1 than I did in the mid 6's. I can only imagine how good 4.2-4.6 could feel.

    Doris J. Dickson

     

     

    Comments (1):
    Sort By
  • Add Comment

  • By: FatCatAnna: Mar, 02, 2009 23:26 PM

    I am puzzled by your writing about how " much better I feel at 5.1 than I did in the mid 6's ".  Can you expand abit on what is different? 

    If you are referring to your A1C numbers - I have to admit - I haven't really noticed much of a change of how I feel from a 7.0 reading to the last A1C reading of 5.9 that I attained since being on an insulin pump.

    On the other hand if you are referring to vampire readings (BG meter).  I feel like a stand up comedian when I'm below 3.0 mmol/L (54 mg/dL).  Now since being on the pump I know when I'm going up much faster for some reason - which isn't often - but when I do - I can tell usually by irritability / getting abit flushed / thirsty. 

    I like your comment on " female hormones; avoid them if possible " - who knows what will happen to me when I hit menopause - ehgads - I'm going to be Godzilla recreated - watch out NYC!



    Tags:

    Related posts:

  • Previous Blog Post
  • Next Blog Post
  • What is Diabetes? (Part 2)
    Target Blood Glucose Range-What is Diabetes?
    An explanation of the concept of "target blood glucose range."...
    more more Featured Videos
    Cost Savings Tool
    Do you know the annual cost of managing your diabetes? Would you like to find ways to reduce your costs? Calculate your total budget and identify ways to save money. You can do this in just a few minutes by entering facts about the products you use. This quick analysis will provide you with a comprehensive overview of both spending and potential savings.

    Cost Savings Tool
    Monitor Comparison Tools
    Blood glucose monitors offer an easy way to test your blood sugar at home or on the go. Use this comparison tool as a guide to learn more about the features and benefits of your current monitor or to find a new one.
    Handheld Monitor Comparison
    Continuous Glucose Monitor Comparison
    Advanced BMI Calculator
    Ever wonder if you are at a healthy weight? Then enter your height and weight in our advanced Body Mass Index (BMI) calculator. This tool provides you with two important numbers reflecting the estimated impact of your present body weight and shape upon your overall health.
    Advanced BMI Calculator
    more Care Tools
    Home | About Us | Press | Make a Suggestion | Content Syndication | Terms of Service | Editorial Policy | Privacy Policy
    Last updated: Sep 15, 2019  © 2019 Body1 All rights reserved.