Home
 »  Community
 »  Blogs
Doris' Blog

Are all diabetics overweight?


Doris' Blog
By: dorisjdickson


<< February 2009 >>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28

 Blog Entries
Islet Cells Generation - Cure? I Think Not! - Oct 01
This article in Diabetes Health discusses yet another new potential "cure."  However, yet again, it requires immunosuppressants which are not an option to me.  ...
more
Cholesterol Conundrum - Sep 21
I recently wrote about Red Yeast Rice as an alternative to statins and the fact that it actually IS a statin since they contain the same active ingredients.  You just ...
more
Red Yeast Rice - It is a Statin - Do I Take It? - Sep 10
I receive Dr. Mercola's newsletter regularly.  I don't, however, regularly read it.  My concern is the amount of "stuff" sold on the website.  However, this ...
more
Diabetic ketoacidosis at onset of type 1 diabetes remains frequent in children - Sep 08
This article in yesterday's edition of Endocrine Today makes me scratch my head.  First and foremost, had this study been conducted in 1976 in the US and not in Germany, ...
more
Inaccurate Monitors and Strips - Sep 02
Some of you may have read about the FDA's recent warning about the inaccuracy of certain test strips while taking certain medications.  Honestly, I didn't pay much attention ...
more
Posted: Feb 25, 2009 8:42
  • 1 Comment.
  • Are all diabetics overweight?

    I think not!  More than thirty-two years following my diagnosis of juvenile-onset diabetes at age 12, I am still thin by any standards.  I do not exercise for hours on end to maintain that weight.  I do not starve to death.  I have and attempt to attain “normalized” blood sugar targets. 

     

    So then, why do most articles, news clips and commercials on diabetes assume all diabetics are overweight and need to lose weight?  Why do so many newly diagnosed diabetics write and ask, “Will I gain weight?  My doctor says insulin will make me gain weight.”  Others write asking, “I take insulin; I can not lose weight.  Help me!” 

     

    These fallacies seem to be a fairly, new occurrence.  I sure never heard these assumptions for the first 25 or 30 years following my diagnosis.  I also never felt inundated and annoyed by “lose weight,” “lose weight” articles.  Welcome to the world of 6% type 1, 94% type 2 diabetes?

     

    So, what is the truth?  The truth is not all diabetics are overweight.  Not all diabetics were ever overweight and not all diabetics who take insulin gain weight. 

     

    So, what do we tell insulin dependent diabetics?  We tell diabetics that if they eat more than they need to eat, take more insulin to cover the excess food, and do not “spit” excess nourishment into their urine, the body allocates it to fat.  Insulin takes any excess nourishment and converts it to fat.  Therefore, like anyone else, it is fairly simple.  Do not eat more food than you need!

     

    We also tell diabetics who take excess long acting (or basal) insulin and experience frequent low blood sugar (because of the excess insulin) to do basal testing and properly balance their long acting insulin.  When diabetics take too much long acting (or basal insulin) for whatever reason, (e.g. the doctor said so, to extend the duration to match pharmaceutical claims, because it is easier than dealing with late digesting food, they perceived insulin resistant, etc.) and they subsequently have low blood sugar caused by insulin peaks, they eat/treat the low blood sugar with further excess nourishment.  Frequently, diabetics over treat these lows due to panic or due to the “hungry horrors” at 2 a.m. and frequently, it leads to rapid weight gain.

     

    However, this weight gain does not have to occur and poor glucose levels do not have be the alternative.  In addition, not every article written needs to assume and describe how diabetics have to lose weight. 

     

    What the articles should describe is how many total calories a person of a particular age, height, target weight and activity level needs.  The articles should describe how to count ALL food (not just carbohydrates) in order to assess total calorie requirements.  The articles should describe how to properly take insulin at appropriate times (to address varied digestion) to address all food intake (not just carbohydrates) to avoid low blood sugar followed by high blood sugar.  They should describe how to do basal testing and multiple long acting doses in order to avoid peaks, lows, and gaps.

     

    So, to the editors of diabetes journals and websites, Certified Diabetes Educators, endocrinologists, primary care physicians, etc. PLEASE stop assuming all diabetics have weight to lose.  Please DO address the difficult topics diabetics need to understand the not so easy topics (digestion, multiple doses of insulin, basal/bolus testing, etc.). 

     

    With proper treatment information, insulin dependent diabetics do not have to be overweight or ever have weight to lose.  However, if they are repeatedly told to take too much insulin (because no one has a better answer) or not told how to properly calculate either basal or bolus (long acting or short acting) insulin requirements, they will continue to fear weight gain by virtue of a life sustaining hormone.  And, please, there are plenty of other vitally important topics on which to focus.  Listen to your patients; they will tell you what they are.

     

    Doris J. Dickson

     

     

    Comments (1):
    Sort By
  • Add Comment

  • By: FatCatAnna: Feb, 25, 2009 11:25 AM

    Insulin diabetics are still the smaller percentage of population that become diabetics I'm afraid to say since you are writing specifically about Type 1 diabetics.  I find that the advertising / articles on TV / Internet are aimed at the public that "might" eventually end up with Type 2 diabetes (we are seeing it more here in Canada with children now - due to diet/exercise - sigh). 

    Type 2's that I have met a monthly diabetic meetings tend to have a weight issue - and other health issues as well (and are older).  By excercising and eating correctly they can hopefully avoid going the route of insulin injections to maintain a healthy life.  Whether they take the advise of their medical staff is up to them - I know for myself - I take everything I read / hear with a grain of salt - and pursue further - but others may not do that.   Many are very scared about having diabetes - and fear stepping outside of the medical advise given to them - will cause more problems.

    As a long time insulin user - when people discover that I'm a diabetic - they are surprised that I have it - as they tell me I don't look like a diabetic (I show them the DDD hidden under my hairline).  Then they say "you're not overweight - so why do I have diabetes?". I tell them luck of the straw - no one asked me at the age of 7 if I wanted it. <lol>  I don't take offense to their comment(s) because ... I am overweight by the standards set by the health industry here in Canada (and also the BMI Calculator here on the website - it's no news to me).  I tell them this - and they seemed shocked - but it's all in the eyes of the beholder (plus clothing sure helps <lol>). 

    Remember, we are all different in how we burn off food, etc. etc.  The same applies to the ways we handle our health problems - what works for one person, may not work for others (garlic clove gently shoved up the nostril can cure sinus problems - really!!).



    Tags:

    Related posts:

  • Previous Blog Post
  • Next Blog Post
  • Diabetes Control in Children
    In this follow up video to "Diabetes Diagnosis in Children," Dr. Fort ...
    more more Featured Videos
    Cost Savings Tool
    Do you know the annual cost of managing your diabetes? Would you like to find ways to reduce your costs? Calculate your total budget and identify ways to save money. You can do this in just a few minutes by entering facts about the products you use. This quick analysis will provide you with a comprehensive overview of both spending and potential savings.

    Cost Savings Tool
    Monitor Comparison Tools
    Blood glucose monitors offer an easy way to test your blood sugar at home or on the go. Use this comparison tool as a guide to learn more about the features and benefits of your current monitor or to find a new one.
    Handheld Monitor Comparison
    Continuous Glucose Monitor Comparison
    Advanced BMI Calculator
    Ever wonder if you are at a healthy weight? Then enter your height and weight in our advanced Body Mass Index (BMI) calculator. This tool provides you with two important numbers reflecting the estimated impact of your present body weight and shape upon your overall health.
    Advanced BMI Calculator
    more Care Tools
    Home | About Us | Press | Make a Suggestion | Content Syndication | Terms of Service | Editorial Policy | Privacy Policy
    Last updated: Dec 11, 2019  © 2019 Body1 All rights reserved.